Why society assigns gender based on biological sex

SarahEL · 2023-04-26 18:32:39

On a very basic level it is biology/history. Born with a vagina, then probably you will be able to carry a baby to term and so increase the population of your tribe you will be less expendable in wars as if you were born with a penis you could impregnate multiple females in one day, but a female can only carry one pregnancy every 9 months or so. So society evolves to subjugate women to subservient roles, child rearing and homestead keeping.
As our society evolves it gets less important to so closely define these roles, population is high and growing. That allows exploration of "gendered" roles. I have been married for 27 years, at times my wife has been the breadwinner, for the last 12 years, after the birth of our child, she was the sole breadwinner, I was the home-carer, child-carer. Our society allowed it at the time (and still does) by removing the shackles of inequality. It gets better.
We will be soon able to generate foetuses with either gamete, then a little more of the gender specificity will be eroded, pregnancy in a tube until birth, more still degrade.
At the moment there is no reason to have gender identifiers on any legal document - not one gender confers any benefit over another (in the UK, gender equality act sorted that, or should of), society is slow to move, but is moving in the direction towards gender neutrality.
Still, I doubt we will ever stop the personal identification of individuals and them having their choice freely of where on the gender spectrum they want to identify. (this is not a binary problem).

SarahEL · 2023-05-26 18:14:42

Throughout history, society has observed distinct physical differences between males and females. These observations, particularly related to reproductive capabilities, have influenced the development of gender roles. Men took on physically demanding tasks, while women assumed caregiving roles. This historical context has contributed to the assignment of gender based on biological sex.

One of the reasons society assigns gender based on biological sex is to maintain social stability and order. By adhering to predefined gender norms, societies establish a predictable framework. These roles and responsibilities ensure smooth functioning and harmony within the community. It provides a sense of structure and familiarity that contributes to social stability.

The connection between sex and reproduction plays a significant role in assigning gender roles. Women's unique ability to bear children has often associated them with nurturing and caregiving roles, while men have been expected to be protectors and providers. This division of labour ensures the survival and well-being of families and communities, as each gender plays a distinct role in the dynamics of reproduction and family life.

Culture and religion have a profound influence on assigning gender. Many cultures and religions embrace the concept of gender complementarity, where each gender has specific qualities and roles that complement one another. These beliefs, passed down through generations, become deeply ingrained in traditions, reinforcing the link between gender and biological sex.

Power dynamics and patriarchal systems have played a role in the assignment of gender. Throughout history, men have often held positions of power and authority. Assigning specific gender roles has reinforced this power structure, with men dominating in public spheres while women are confined to private ones, limiting their access to influential positions. This dynamic perpetuates the existing power imbalances within society.

Despite societal norms, movements advocating for gender equality and fluidity have emerged. Feminism, LGBTQ+ rights activism, and other progressive movements challenge rigid gender assignments. These movements strive for inclusivity, celebrating the diverse nature of gender identities and encouraging individuals to express themselves authentically. They represent a shift toward a more inclusive understanding of gender beyond the constraints of biological sex.

The assignment of gender is a complex phenomenon shaped by historical, social, cultural, and power-related factors. While it has provided certain societal functions, it has also perpetuated inequalities and limited individual expression. As society evolves, there is an increasing recognition of the need to embrace a more inclusive and fluid understanding of gender. By questioning and challenging assigned gender roles, we can work towards a more equitable and understanding society that celebrates the diversity of gender identities.

Transgender Action Online

Defending, Embracing and Supporting the Gender Spectrum.

Announcement

#1 2023-04-26 18:32:39

Why society assigns gender based on biological sex

#2 2023-05-26 18:14:42

Re: Why society assigns gender based on biological sex

Board footer